Collusion allegation: AUS bank and franchisor

September 18, 2008

In a Smart Company article by James Thomson called MP renews calls for investigations into mistreatment of Bakers Delight franchisee, he quotes:

NSW parliamentarian Joanna Gash has renewed calls for the Australian Federal Police to launch an investigation into accusations Bakers Delight and ANZ bank colluded to put a franchisee out of business.

Quoting emails between the franchisor and the bank, Gash alleges:

On Monday, Gash revisited the case in Parliament, producing emails from Bakers Delight chief financial officer Richard Taylor and ANZ executives that she says shows “plans had been conspired to terminate Ms de Leeuw’s franchise well ahead of time”.

The bank and franchisor deny all the allegations.

This is the first public AUS public allegation of the key franchisor:franchise banker relationship that I identified and wrote about in a 2005 paper for Industry Canada called Franchising Opportunism [free download].

The Royal Canadian Mounted Police did a 10 month investigation of a related predatory franchise lending matter. [free download: Mounties investigate ‘predatory lending’, Ottawa Citizen, March 25, 2006]

And Mr. Oudovikine is accusing the bank of transferring the loans to Country Style without his authorization before he had a chance to obtain a business plan and other financial details from Country Style.

Mr. Oudovikine says his case shows how big banks, franchisors and franchise brokers team up to take advantage of franchisees, many of whom are recent immigrants like him.

“It’s predatory lending. (CIBC) didn’t do any of the due diligence they should have done,” says Mr. Oudovikine, who sent the Citizen e-mails confirming the RCMP investigation. An RCMP official said the police force doesn’t confirm or deny investigation.

And the Canadian bank’s reaction?

Mr. Oudovikine says he has repeatedly contacted senior CIBC officials and executives about the loan dispute, to little effect. He alleges that CIBC breached the Canada Small Business Financing Act regulations that require lenders to conduct due diligence on borrowers, including their ability to repay loans.

Advertisements

Franchisee Narrative

February 25, 2008

It is very useful for a franchisee to write down in their own words a history of what happened from their point of view.

This is an outstanding example of a franchise investor’s narrative. In July 2005, it was written in preparation of what would become a 10 month-long Royal Canadian Mounted Police, Commercial Crime Section investigation.

We would like to help reduce the risk of franchise relationships being used as a vehicle for increased white-collar crime in Ontario. The high cost of litigation and franchisor intimidation make Ontario franchisees defenseless.

Several stakeholders, with this lender only being an example, exploit this systemic problem. Current Ontario franchise policy actually increases the risk to small business investors.

Thank you again and I look forward to working with you.

The RCMP officers were kind enough to suggest that a lawsuit was always possible when they informed the Oudovikines that they would be stopping their criminal investigation.


%d bloggers like this: